<!-- Plain-text version of https://kyc.co/inventions/GB9804037D0 for AI readers, 2026-11-20. Every claim links to its source on the page. -->

Invention ·  GB9804037.1application ·  1998-02-01 · CARROLL STEVEN

# Turntable and coded record that control playback of digital music

Cite this on a line: [[patent:GB9804037.1application]]

Work 3 of 21 dated on the dvs line, 3 years after the first documented work (WO1997001168A1).

## What happened to this patent

Let lapse: renewal fees not paid ·  not in force: renewal fees not paid (date not held)

A grant is a presumption, not a proof: the status is read from the record below. Its weight as evidence of origin: 0.5 (survived a challenge 1.0 · never challenged 0.6 · let lapse 0.5 · contested 0.3 · abandoned under challenge 0).

| When | What the record shows | Where |
| 1998-02-25 | Application filed by CARROLL STEVEN | GB9804037D0 |
| 1998-02-25 | Priority to GBGB9804037.1A | GB9804037D0 |
| 1998-04-22 | Publication of GB9804037D0 | GB9804037D0 |
| undated | Ceased | GB9804037D0 |

## Earlier work on the same line, before its priority (1998-02-01)

- [Bauer Middlesex DVS prototype (1998 MA thesis)](https://kyc.co/products/576be81c-b6e6-4721-9442-9981556cc796) Chris Bauer · 1998-01-01 · success

Dated work by other makers that came before the patent's priority date: prior art for a reader to weigh, whether or not the examiner saw it.

## How it was examined

## Earlier patents on this line that were not cited

- [WO1997001168A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/WO1997001168A1) 1995-06-20 · Digital processing device for audio signal · Individual

Published patents on the same line, earlier than this one's filing, that neither the examiner nor the applicant cited (family members of a citation count as cited). The examiner may have had reasons; the earlier art is on the record for a reader to weigh.

The office's own examination record (search, objections, amendments, grant) is not held yet for this patent.

## The filing itself

At the office: [UK Intellectual Property Office](https://www.search-for-intellectual-property.service.gov.uk/GB9804037.1) — the case record only: the application was not published, so the office shows its filing and status, not its text

Held: [UK patent application 9804037.1 — Digital control device (filing receipt and specification, filed 25 Feb 1998)](https://kyc.co/documents/25df3af7-773e-46e1-94fa-2614f7578b5f) · [open the file](https://kyc.co/documents/25df3af7-773e-46e1-94fa-2614f7578b5f/file)

Held: [dvs patent receipt](https://kyc.co/documents/806f68f5-90b0-4cf3-b607-7cca3e3e0554) · [open the file](https://kyc.co/documents/806f68f5-90b0-4cf3-b607-7cca3e3e0554/file)

## Compare its claims

Claim by claim against another patent on the same line, with the pair placed among every pair on the line:

[WO1997001168A1 1995](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/WO1997001168A1) [EP0973162A2 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/EP0973162A2) [US6576825B2 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US6576825B2) [EP0977171A1 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/EP0977171A1) [US7012184B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US7012184B2) [US7238874B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US7238874B2) [US8680385B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US8680385B2) [EP1312090B1 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/EP1312090B1) [US7394731B2 2001](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US7394731B2) [DE10206644C1 2002](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/DE10206644C1) [US7273980B2 2004](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/GB9804037.1application/US7273980B2)

## The problem

DJs use record players because they can touch the record and control the speed, pitch and direction of a song. They use scratching and mixing, and a slipmat makes both easier. The text says there was no way to do these things with digital recordings. The invention aims to give a user the same hands-on control over digitised information.

## The idea

A normal record player spins a special record that carries control pulses instead of music. Those pulses control how a computer or other digital player plays stored music. A DJ can then scratch, mix and slow or reverse digital tracks by touching a record, as they would with a vinyl record.

## How it works

A record player carries a specially made record. Its left and right channels hold series of tone pulses, recorded slightly out of step with each other. The track is long enough to last as long as the longest piece of music stored on the computer. Before playing, the DJ uses buttons on an interface device to pick passages from stored pieces. Several passages can be ready at once. When the record spins under the stylus, the pulses go to circuitry in the interface device and then to the computer, and the selected piece starts playing. The pulse rate sets the playback speed. The gap between the left and right pulses sets the direction. Counting pulses shows the position in the piece, and this can be shown on a screen. Normal rotation gives normal playback. If the DJ lets the record slip on the platter, or holds it and moves it back and forth, the audio changes in the same way. The output goes to an amplifier and loudspeaker. In a second embodiment, everything is combined in one apparatus, with a computer and a conventional record player.

## The claims, in plain words

- A control system has a unit that plays a digitally recorded piece, and a controller made of a disc whose track is read by a transducer. The piece plays when the disc turns, and an operator can control the disc's speed and direction.
- The disc's speed and direction are preferably set by direct touch of the hand.
- The controller may be a record player, with a track recorded like a normal record track, with left and right channels read by a stylus.
- A second system has a disc whose track carries a coding that itself manipulates the output of the playback unit.
- A rotatable disc has two pre-recorded channels. The first holds evenly spaced pulses. The second holds pulses with the same spacing, but staggered unevenly against the first.
- Claims as filed are not held. The three aspects above come from the description, which the filing receipt lists as filed without claims.

## How broad it is

The playback unit can be a computer, a mini disc player, a suitably modified CD player or any digital sound device. It can be separate from the controller or built into it. The signals may be audio, video or any information that can be manipulated. The disc may be read by a stylus, taken from the spindle, or read optically or by laser. The control track can be a single channel, though at least three successive different pulses are preferred so direction can be found. A position code like SMPTE is also mentioned. A switch could let the player play ordinary records. The text states no limits beyond these.

A machine's plain-language description of the patent's own text (antigravity:claude-sonnet-5-5-medium, 2026-11-20), not a legal opinion on validity or infringement. Read from: GB9804037.1-filing-receipt.txt (capture, readability 0.928); GB9804037.1-specification.txt (capture, readability 0.925); GB9804037.1-ipo.txt (capture, readability 0.919); who-invented-digital-vinyl.pdf (ocr, readability 0.913); who-invented-digital-vinyl.txt (plain, readability 0.908).

Named on the patent1

- [**CARROLL STEVEN**](https://kyc.co/entities/b1fed754-5315-466f-94f9-86da011b013f)  named as owner (assignee) ·

The same name on 1 other patent held (a name match): [GB9205279D0](https://kyc.co/inventions/GB9205279D0) (1992)

Products by the same maker1

- [Carroll DVS — timecode vinyl concept](https://kyc.co/products/78d47b61-a9dc-4587-80b7-03da1ee87c35) 1998 · prototype  not yet linked to this patent ·

Products made by Carroll, Steven. Whether a product uses this patent is shown only once someone links it with a source (a patent-marking page, a manual, a court record).

Photographs1

[dvs patent receipt](https://kyc.co/documents/806f68f5-90b0-4cf3-b607-7cca3e3e0554)

People and companies1

- [**Carroll, Steven**](https://kyc.co/entities/b1fed754-5315-466f-94f9-86da011b013f)  named as inventor (claimed) ·  their card: companies, ties, documents

Related products, patents and papers1

- builds on ·  [Digital processing device for audio signal](https://kyc.co/inventions/WO1997001168A1) patent · André Rickli · 1995

> “This story started for me and probably everyone else when Andre Rickli from Bern Switzerland demonstrated (I think it was) in 1996 at Frankfurt Musikmesse a device which ... was used to capture the movement of the disc. As the DJ moved the disc back and forth so would the sample being played from his computer.”

Disputes and cases3

- **Third-party observations against N2IT application EP 01 908 437.5 (EPO)**  patent office ·  unknown ·

European Patent Office (Examining Division; Board of Appeal) · EP 01 908 437.5 · 2003-12 · shown because it filed on its line

Prior art from Chris Bauer's 1998 Middlesex MA thesis/prototype put to the EPO against N2IT's Final Scratch application; N2IT responded 9 Apr 2004; refusal and appeal followed.

- **2003-12-03** · filed: Observations by third party filed against EP 01 908 437.5 [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **2004-01-01** · decision: Application refused (per outside summary; date of refusal not sourced)
- **2004-04-09** · motion: Applicant (N2IT) response to the third-party observations [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **2005-12-23** · appeal: Board of Appeal: patent granted on appeal (per outside summary; the reference 'EPO Appeal … Dec. 23, 2005' is cited in US 8,680,385) [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
 [the record](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **n2it v Native Instruments**  lawsuit ·  unknown ·

US District Court (CACD), R. Gary Klausner; referred to Victor B. Kenton · 2:07-cv-03321 · 2007-05–2007-07 · shown because it filed on its line

First court case brought by n2it, against Native Instruments, the Berlin company that wrote the software for Final Scratch and then launched Traktor. Per Carroll it ended the Final Scratch branch.

 [the record](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/12291420/n2it-holding-bv-v-native-instruments-north-america-inc/)
- **n2it v M-Audio / Avid**  patent suit ·  unknown ·

US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller · 2:08-cv-00619 · 2008-12–2009-11 · shown because it filed on its line

n2it against M-Audio and its parent Avid Technology (NASDAQ-listed): per Carroll, a listed company against a tiny inventor. Avid had top-tier counsel, a firm that also acted in Apple v Samsung (firm not named yet). An insider was involved: a director who moved from Avid to Stanton (not named yet). A...

- **2009-09-04** · counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.) [source](https://djtechtools.com/2009/11/29/n2its-lawsuit-against-m-audio-dismissed/)
- **2009-11-01** · ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held) [source](https://djtechtools.com/2009/11/29/n2its-lawsuit-against-m-audio-dismissed/)
- **undated** · prior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.

Documents on this case: 45 The M Audio Torq Connection Paul Whittington and The N2IT Patent Sh...  lead, not evidence ·  · 57 The N2IT v M Audio Litigation Audit Hallucination vs Docket Reality... · 55 The N2IT v M Audio Federal Litigation Dossier EDVa 08cv619  lead, not evidence ·

 [the record](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/60721771/n2it-holding-bv-v-m-audio-llc/)

A case is shown as filed and decided, in its own words; it is not a finding of this index.

## Documents in the family

- GB9804037.1application · priority 1998-02-01 [Google Patents](https://patents.google.com/patent/GB98040371APPLICATION)
- GB9804037D0 · priority 1998-02-25 · published 1998-04-22 · [source](https://patents.google.com/patent/GB9804037D0/en) [Google Patents](https://patents.google.com/patent/GB9804037D0)

Cited by 0 later documents held.

What we are still finding out3

- Which products use the invention in GB9804037.1application, and on what evidence (patent marking, manuals, court records)?  open ·
- Was GB9804037.1application litigated, opposed or licensed? Name the cases, forums and outcomes, with sources.  open ·
- What does GB9804037.1application cite, and what later patents cite it?  no answer yet ·

The index asks these itself, every night, for each relationship a page like this should have; research questions run when someone asks. Each answer says what kind of witness gave it. Answers are leads until a person confirms them, and marking them useful or wrong teaches the index which provider to ask next time.

The documents4

## Patent documents 1

- [UK patent application 9804037.1 — Digital control device (filing receipt and specification...](https://kyc.co/documents/25df3af7-773e-46e1-94fa-2614f7578b5f) Steven Carroll's case files · 1998-02 [the original](https://kyc.co/documents/25df3af7-773e-46e1-94fa-2614f7578b5f/file)

3 more documents are held but not shown publicly (write-ups, typed copies and other kinds that can carry private details).
