<!-- Plain-text version of https://kyc.co/inventions/US7394731B2 for AI readers, 2026-11-20. Every claim links to its source on the page. -->

Invention ·  US7394731B2 ·  2001-05-21 · Pioneer Corp

# Jog dial that lets you scratch digital discs like vinyl records

Cite this on a line: [[patent:US7394731B2]]

Work 9 of 21 dated on the dvs line, 6 years after the first documented work (WO1997001168A1).

## What happened to this patent

Expired at the end of its term; never challenged on the record ·  expired at the end of its term

A grant is a presumption, not a proof: the status is read from the record below. Its weight as evidence of origin: 0.6 (survived a challenge 1.0 · never challenged 0.6 · let lapse 0.5 · contested 0.3 · abandoned under challenge 0).

| When | What the record shows | Where |
| 2006-04-11 | Application filed by Pioneer Corp | US7394731B2 |
| 2006-04-11 | Priority to US11/401,327 | US7394731B2 |
| 2006-06-22 | Assigned to PIONEER CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2006-08-17 | Publication of US20060181968A1 | US7394731B2 |
| 2008-07-01 | Application granted | US7394731B2 |
| 2008-07-01 | Publication of US7394731B2 | US7394731B2 |
| 2014-12-09 | Assigned to PIONEER CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2015-03-30 | Assigned to PIONEER DJ CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2015-12-01 | Assigned to PDJ HOLDINGS CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2015-12-03 | Assigned to PIONEER DJ CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2020-06-05 | Assigned to ALPHATHETA CORPORATION | ownership |
| 2022-05-21 | Anticipated expiration | US7394731B2 |
| undated | Expired - Lifetime | US7394731B2 |

## Earlier work on the same line, before its priority (2001-05-21)

- [Bauer Middlesex DVS prototype (1998 MA thesis)](https://kyc.co/products/576be81c-b6e6-4721-9442-9981556cc796) Chris Bauer · 1998-01-01 · success
- [Carroll DVS — timecode vinyl concept](https://kyc.co/products/78d47b61-a9dc-4587-80b7-03da1ee87c35) Carroll, Steven · 1998-02-01 · prototype

Dated work by other makers that came before the patent's priority date: prior art for a reader to weigh, whether or not the examiner saw it.

## How it was examined

## Earlier patents on this line that were not cited

- [EP0973162A2](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0973162A2) 1998-07-09 · System for reproducing information recorded on a disc · Pioneer Electronic Corp

Published patents on the same line, earlier than this one's filing, that neither the examiner nor the applicant cited (family members of a citation count as cited). The examiner may have had reasons; the earlier art is on the record for a reader to weigh.

Earlier filings on this line that were not published by this patent's filing date, so could not have been cited: [GB9804037.1application](https://kyc.co/inventions/GB9804037.1application) (1998-02-01), [US7238874B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7238874B2) (2000-02-29), [GB9804037D0](https://kyc.co/inventions/GB9804037D0) (1998-02-25), [US8680385B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US8680385B2) (2000-02-29), [EP1312090B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP1312090B1) (2000-02-29), [US7012184B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7012184B2) (2000-02-29), [US6576825B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6576825B2) (1998-07-09).

The office's own examination record (search, objections, amendments, grant) is not held yet for this patent.

## The filing itself

At the office: [USPTO Patent Center](https://patentcenter.uspto.gov/applications/11401327) — the file history (office actions, responses, amendments)

At the office: [Espacenet](https://worldwide.espacenet.com/patent/search?q=pn%3DUS7394731B2)

## Compare its claims

Claim by claim against another patent on the same line, with the pair placed among every pair on the line:

[WO1997001168A1 1995](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/WO1997001168A1) [GB9804037D0 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/GB9804037D0) [US6576825B2 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/US6576825B2) [EP0973162A2 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/EP0973162A2) [EP0977171A1 1998](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/EP0977171A1) [EP1312090B1 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/EP1312090B1) [US7238874B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/US7238874B2) [US8680385B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/US8680385B2) [US7012184B2 2000](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/US7012184B2) [DE10206644C1 2002](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/DE10206644C1) [US7273980B2 2004](https://kyc.co/innovation-index/compare/US7394731B2/US7273980B2)

## The problem

With analog record players, performers could create editing effects by forcing the record to change direction and speed by hand. Digital discs such as CDs and DVDs store information with a special technology that people cannot grasp by intuition. It is therefore hard to get the same hand-operated effects from them.

## The idea

A playback device for digital discs such as CDs has a rotatable jog dial that senses how hard it is pressed and how far it is turned. Pressing and turning the dial changes playback in the way hand-turning an analog record does. This gives editing and sound effects the same hand-operated feel that analog record players gave.

## How it works

The apparatus has a rotating body, which is a jog dial turned by hand. A sensing unit detects whether the dial is being pressed and how hard. A detecting unit measures how far the dial is rotated. A control unit reads both outputs and picks one of three behaviors. First, if the pressing force is weaker than a set level and the dial is not turning, the digital information plays back normally. Second, if the set pressing force is applied and the dial is not turning, playback stops, like holding a record still. Third, if the set pressing force is applied and the dial is turned, playback is controlled according to how far the dial turns. The abstract adds that sound-effect processing is applied to the playback data from the disc in response to the rotation amount.

## The claims, in plain words

- A digital information playback apparatus has a hand-rotatable body, a unit that senses pressing force on it, a unit that detects how far it rotates, and a control unit that performs three kinds of control based on those outputs.
- First control: when the pressing force is below a set level and the body is not rotated, the digital information plays back.
- Second control: when the set pressing force is applied and the body is not rotated, playback stops.
- Third control: when the set pressing force is applied and the body is rotated, playback is controlled according to the rotation amount.

## How broad it is

The text describes the apparatus mainly as an audio editing device that plays optical discs such as CDs, and it also mentions DVDs as digital storage media. The claim covers digital information playback with a hand-turned rotating body, pressure sensing and rotation detection. The text held does not state other media, other uses or specific effect types beyond sound effects on playback data.

A machine's plain-language description of the patent's own text (antigravity:claude-sonnet-5-5-medium, 2026-11-20), not a legal opinion on validity or infringement. Read from the claim and abstract held only.

Named on the patent10

- [Yoichi Yamada](https://kyc.co/find?q=Yoichi%20Yamada)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 6 other patents held (a name match): [JPH08201542A](https://kyc.co/inventions/JPH08201542A) (1995), [US6301365B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6301365B1) (1995), [US5614687A](https://kyc.co/inventions/US5614687A) (1995), [US6343055B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6343055B1) (1998), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001)
- [Tomohiko Kimura](https://kyc.co/find?q=Tomohiko%20Kimura)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 6 other patents held (a name match): [JPH08201542A](https://kyc.co/inventions/JPH08201542A) (1995), [US5614687A](https://kyc.co/inventions/US5614687A) (1995), [US6576825B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6576825B2) (1998), [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001)
- [Koichiro Sakata](https://kyc.co/find?q=Koichiro%20Sakata)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 3 other patents held (a name match): [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001)
- [Takeaki Funada](https://kyc.co/find?q=Takeaki%20Funada)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 7 other patents held (a name match): [JPH08201542A](https://kyc.co/inventions/JPH08201542A) (1995), [US6301365B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6301365B1) (1995), [US5614687A](https://kyc.co/inventions/US5614687A) (1995), [US6822152B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6822152B2) (1998), [EP0977171A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0977171A1) (1998), [EP2267714A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP2267714A1) (1999), [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999)
- [Hiroyuki Isobe](https://kyc.co/find?q=Hiroyuki%20Isobe)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 6 other patents held (a name match): [US6576825B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6576825B2) (1998), [US6822152B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6822152B2) (1998), [EP0977171A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0977171A1) (1998), [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001)
- [Junichi Takagaki](https://kyc.co/find?q=Junichi%20Takagaki)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 1 other patent held (a name match): [EP2267714A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP2267714A1) (1999)
- [Tetsuya Kikuchi](https://kyc.co/find?q=Tetsuya%20Kikuchi)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search
- [Gen Inoshita](https://kyc.co/find?q=Gen%20Inoshita)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 9 other patents held (a name match): [US6301365B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6301365B1) (1995), [US5614687A](https://kyc.co/inventions/US5614687A) (1995), [US6576825B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6576825B2) (1998), [EP0977171A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0977171A1) (1998), [US6822152B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6822152B2) (1998), [EP2267714A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP2267714A1) (1999), [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001)
- [Ko Atsumi](https://kyc.co/find?q=Ko%20Atsumi)  named as inventor (claimed) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 5 other patents held (a name match): [US6576825B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6576825B2) (1998), [US6822152B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6822152B2) (1998), [EP0977171A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0977171A1) (1998), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001)
- [Pioneer Corp](https://kyc.co/find?q=Pioneer%20Corp)  named as owner (assignee) · not yet linked to a held record: the name opens a search

The same name on 8 other patents held (a name match): [EP1073055A2](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP1073055A2) (1999), [EP2267714A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP2267714A1) (1999), [US6831883B1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US6831883B1) (1999), [US20060146659A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20060146659A1) (2001), [EP1258879A3](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP1258879A3) (2001), [US7031243B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US7031243B2) (2001), [US8344234B2](https://kyc.co/inventions/US8344234B2) (2008), [US20110067555A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/US20110067555A1) (2008)

Disputes and cases3

- **Third-party observations against N2IT application EP 01 908 437.5 (EPO)**  patent office ·  unknown ·

European Patent Office (Examining Division; Board of Appeal) · EP 01 908 437.5 · 2003-12 · shown because it filed on its line

Prior art from Chris Bauer's 1998 Middlesex MA thesis/prototype put to the EPO against N2IT's Final Scratch application; N2IT responded 9 Apr 2004; refusal and appeal followed.

- **2003-12-03** · filed: Observations by third party filed against EP 01 908 437.5 [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **2004-01-01** · decision: Application refused (per outside summary; date of refusal not sourced)
- **2004-04-09** · motion: Applicant (N2IT) response to the third-party observations [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **2005-12-23** · appeal: Board of Appeal: patent granted on appeal (per outside summary; the reference 'EPO Appeal … Dec. 23, 2005' is cited in US 8,680,385) [source](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
 [the record](http://www.freepatentsonline.com/8680385.html)
- **n2it v Native Instruments**  lawsuit ·  unknown ·

US District Court (CACD), R. Gary Klausner; referred to Victor B. Kenton · 2:07-cv-03321 · 2007-05–2007-07 · shown because it filed on its line

First court case brought by n2it, against Native Instruments, the Berlin company that wrote the software for Final Scratch and then launched Traktor. Per Carroll it ended the Final Scratch branch.

 [the record](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/12291420/n2it-holding-bv-v-native-instruments-north-america-inc/)
- **n2it v M-Audio / Avid**  patent suit ·  unknown ·

US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller · 2:08-cv-00619 · 2008-12–2009-11 · shown because it filed on its line

n2it against M-Audio and its parent Avid Technology (NASDAQ-listed): per Carroll, a listed company against a tiny inventor. Avid had top-tier counsel, a firm that also acted in Apple v Samsung (firm not named yet). An insider was involved: a director who moved from Avid to Stanton (not named yet). A...

- **2009-09-04** · counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.) [source](https://djtechtools.com/2009/11/29/n2its-lawsuit-against-m-audio-dismissed/)
- **2009-11-01** · ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held) [source](https://djtechtools.com/2009/11/29/n2its-lawsuit-against-m-audio-dismissed/)
- **undated** · prior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.

Documents on this case: 45 The M Audio Torq Connection Paul Whittington and The N2IT Patent Sh...  lead, not evidence ·  · 57 The N2IT v M Audio Litigation Audit Hallucination vs Docket Reality... · 55 The N2IT v M Audio Federal Litigation Dossier EDVa 08cv619  lead, not evidence ·

 [the record](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/60721771/n2it-holding-bv-v-m-audio-llc/)

A case is shown as filed and decided, in its own words; it is not a finding of this index.

## Documents in the family

- US7394731B2 · priority 2001-05-21 · published 2008-07-01 · granted 2008-07-01 · [source](https://patents.google.com/patent/US7394731B2/en) [Google Patents](https://patents.google.com/patent/US7394731B2)

Cited by 35 later documents held.

## Later documents that cite it (35)

- [JP4448650B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP4448650B2/en) · 2002 · パイオニア株式会社

Information processing apparatus, display method, program, recording medium for recording program, and playbac...
- [JP2004188185A](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP2004188185A/en) · 2002 · Swany Corp

wheelchair
- [TW200518045A](https://patents.google.com/patent/TW200518045A/en) · 2003 · Denon Ltd

Optical disc reproducing apparatus and method
- [JP4300162B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP4300162B2/en) · 2004 · 株式会社ディーアンドエムホールディングス

Optical disk playback device
- [JP4741596B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP4741596B2/en) · 2004 · オーディオブラックス インドゥストリア エ コメルシオ デ プロドゥトス エレトロニコス ソシエダッド アノニマ

Portable electronic devices for musical instrument accompaniment and sound evaluation
- [US8300504B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US8300504B2/en) · 2004 · Pioneer Corporation

Switch device, information processing device, and reproduction device
- [KR101403806B1](https://patents.google.com/patent/KR101403806B1/en) · 2005 · 오디오브락스 인더스트리아 에 코메르씨오 데 프로두토스 엘레트로니코스 에스.에이.

Mobile communication device with music instrumental functions
- [KR20070010589A](https://patents.google.com/patent/KR20070010589A/en) · 2005 · 엘지전자 주식회사

Mobile communication terminal provided with a turntable and its operation method
- [US20070091738A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US20070091738A1/en) · 2005 · Shen-Chi Liu

Light producing digital audio signal player
- [US7569762B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US7569762B2/en) · 2006 · Xpresense Llc

RF-based dynamic remote control for audio effects devices or the like
- [US20070175322A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US20070175322A1/en) · 2006 · Xpresense Llc

RF-based dynamic remote control device based on generating and sensing of electrical field in vicinity of the...
- [US20070175321A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US20070175321A1/en) · 2006 · Xpresense Llc

RF-based dynamic remote control for audio effects devices or the like
- [JP2008135147A](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP2008135147A/en) · 2006 · D & M Holdings Inc

Operating element and reproducer
- [US8053660B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US8053660B2/en) · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.

Variable slippage control for a disc jockey control surface
- [US20100080109A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US20100080109A1/en) · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.

Variable Slippage Control For A Disc Jockey Control Surface
- [TW200826078A](https://patents.google.com/patent/TW200826078A/en) · 2006 · Innolux Display Corp

Digital video disc player
- [WO2008107949A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2008107949A1/en) · 2007 · Pioneer Corporation

Information reproducing apparatus and method, and computer program
- [WO2008107948A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2008107948A1/en) · 2007 · Pioneer Corporation

Information reproducing apparatus and method, and computer program
- [WO2008107994A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2008107994A1/en) · 2007 · Pioneer Corporation

Information reproducer and method, and computer program
- [WO2008120397A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2008120397A1/en) · 2007 · Pioneer Corporation

Operation device and information reproducing device
- [US8522242B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US8522242B2/en) · 2007 · Intel Corporation

Conditional batch buffer execution
- [JP5079565B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP5079565B2/en) · 2008 · 株式会社ディーアンドエムホールディングス

Playback apparatus and playback method
- [DE102008035010A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/DE102008035010A1/en) · 2008 · Deutsche Telekom Ag

Method and device for displaying information on an audio and / or video file
- [JP4577438B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP4577438B2/en) · 2008 · ソニー株式会社

Playlist search device, playlist search method, and program
- [JP3147942U](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP3147942U/en) · 2008 · 株式会社ドリームズ

Sound output device
- [US20110094369A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US20110094369A1/en) · 2009 · Shen-Chi Liu

Method for operating cue point on lighting ring of digital multimedia audio player
- [US7964782B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US7964782B2/en) · 2009 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.

Method for operating cue point on lighting ring of digital multimedia audio player
- [JP2012098482A](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP2012098482A/en) · 2010 · Korg Inc

Effect addition device
- [US10135379B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US10135379B2/en) · 2015 · Kabushiki Kaisha Yaskawa Denki

State display device of industrial machinery and power conversion device
- [WO2018129377A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2018129377A1/en) · 2017 · Inmusic Brands, Inc.

Systems and methods for generating a playback-information display during time compression or expansion of an a...
- [WO2018159730A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2018159730A1/en) · 2017 · ヤマハ株式会社

Reproduction system, vibration device, and reproduction system control method
- [JP6923373B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP6923373B2/en) · 2017 · 株式会社デンソーテン

Content playback device and content playback method
- [WO2019176517A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2019176517A1/en) · 2018 · ヤマハ株式会社

Dj device
- [US11863141B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US11863141B2/en) · 2019 · Alphatheta Corporation

Audio equipment including rotary operation unit, operation detecting section, power supplying section, and mon...
- [AT526784B1](https://patents.google.com/patent/AT526784B1/en) · 2023 · Christoph Fussgaenger

Apparatus and method for controlling the playback of digital media files

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

## Earlier documents it cites (14)

- [US5350882A](https://patents.google.com/patent/US5350882A/en) · 1991 · Casio Computer Co., Ltd.

Automatic performance apparatus with operated rotation means for tempo control
- [US5245663A](https://patents.google.com/patent/US5245663A/en) · 1992 · Omar Green

Back-masking effect generator
- [US5512704A](https://patents.google.com/patent/US5512704A/en) · 1992 · Yamaha Corporation

Electronic sound signal generator achieving scratch sound effect using scratch readout from waveform memory
- [JPH0689501A](https://patents.google.com/patent/JPH0689501A/en) · 1993 · Casio Comput Co Ltd

Acoustic signal processor
- [WO1997001168A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/WO1997001168A1) · 1995 · Rickli Andre

Digital processing device for audio signal
- [JPH1186447A](https://patents.google.com/patent/JPH1186447A/en) · 1997 · Sony Corp

Data reproducing apparatus and data reproducing method
- [JP3951403B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/JP3951403B2/en) · 1998 · ソニー株式会社

Playback device
- [EP0977171A1](https://kyc.co/inventions/EP0977171A1) · 1998 · Pioneer Electronic Corporation

Audio signal processing apparatus
- [WO2000021090A1](https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2000021090A1/en) · 1998 · Philippe Borieux

Method and device for manually controlling the direction and speed for data reading with a control disc
- [US6434100B1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US6434100B1/en) · 1999 · Nippon Columbia Co., Ltd.

Optical disc reproducing apparatus
- [US6590840B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US6590840B2/en) · 2000 · Teac Corporation

Recording medium reproduction apparatus
- [US6535462B1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US6535462B1/en) · 2001 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.

Digital sound-signal broadcaster
- [US6751167B2](https://patents.google.com/patent/US6751167B2/en) · 2001 · Pioneer Corporation

Information playback apparatus
- [US6541690B1](https://patents.google.com/patent/US6541690B1/en) · 2001 · Jerry W. Segers, Jr.

Scratch effect controller

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

The documents0

No documents linked yet. Anyone holding one can bring it from the line's "Edit this line".
