GB9804037D0 and EP1312090B1

How closely the two claim sets say the same things, and how unusual that is among the patents on the same line. Closeness of wording is a reason to look, not a finding: these documented facts raise questions; whether anyone had access, and whether the later work was independent, are separate questions shown with their own records.

Earlier

GB9804037D0

Digital control device

CARROLL STEVEN · priority 1998-02-25 · text not published

Later

EP1312090B1

Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing, and such an apparatus

N2IT Holding BV · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2008-02-13

EP1312090B1's priority date is 24 months after GB9804037D0's. GB9804037D0's text was never published, so it could not be cited as prior art; any route from it to the later filing is a question of access, not of the public record.

How close, against the line

0.14 overlap of their claims (0 to 1) — closer than 80% of the 65 other pairs of patents on this line (rank 14; the typical pair scores 0.08).

Each tick is another pair of patents on the line, scored the same way; the dashed line is the typical pair; the dot is this pair.

What was new in GB9804037D0, and what EP1312090B1 repeats

Of GB9804037D0's elements, 13 were new at its date (not said by the 1 earlier patent of the line held); EP1312090B1 repeats 0 of them.

GB9804037D0's elementNew at its dateClosest in EP1312090B1
A digital control system
already said before: “A digital processing device according to claim 3, further”
0.58 0.13 — no counterpart
means for reproducing a digitally recorded piece (ie a song or tune or a part thereof) 0.90 0.11 — no counterpart
a device for controlling the output of the reproducing means 0.91 0.12 — no counterpart
the control device comprising a disc with a track which is read by a transducer 0.91 0.19 — no counterpart
said means reproducing a piece when said disc rotates 0.82 0.23 — no counterpart
the speed and direction of rotation of the disc then being controllable by an operator 0.67 0.14 — no counterpart
means for reproducing a digitally recorded piece 0.88 0.14 — no counterpart
and the track comprising a coding which itself manipulates the output of the reproducing means 0.96 0.06 — no counterpart
A rotatable disc
already said before: “, wherein said element (16) is a rotating element.”
0.59 0.65 “Disc according to claim 1”
first and second channels pre-recorded thereon 1.00 0.13 — no counterpart
the first channel comprising a first plurality of evenly-spaced pulses and the second channel 0.92 0.12 — no counterpart
comprising a second plurality of which have the same even spacing, but which are asymmetrically-staggered with regard to the corresponding pulses of the first plurality 0.94 0.04 — no counterpart
EP1312090B1's claims in GB9804037D0's specification

GB9804037D0's specification discloses 4 of 6 of EP1312090B1's claims (most of a claim's elements found in a passage of a sentence or two). Disclosed there and in no earlier patent (of the line, or cited by EP1312090B1): 0.

The same test on those earlier patents: JP2508972B2 discloses 2; US4300225A discloses 3; US5185805A discloses 1; WO1997001168A1 discloses 4; US5353275A discloses 2; US5350882A discloses 2; US3755792A discloses 3; US4173164A discloses 1; US4176328A discloses 1; US5339301A discloses 3; NL8700655A discloses 4; JP3364824B2 discloses 2; EP0352338B1 discloses 0; US5140614A discloses 1; JP2734909B2 discloses 0; EP0880779A1 discloses 4.

Each of EP1312090B1's claims, element by element
ClaimElements foundWhere
1 (indep.)3 / 4 ✓
0.65 “Disc (1.1) for use in an apparatus for signal processing, wh...” ≈ “In use, buttons 132 are used to select desired passages from desired pieces of m...”
0.42 “a digital audio source (1.10) and a record player (1.6) with...” ≈ “In all cases an electronic circuit (whether that be a stand alone unit, or part...”
0.30 “which disc (1.1) can be placed on the turntable (1.5) and is...”
0.35 “the time-code signal is comprised in both the left and the r...” ≈ “The speed is determined by the frequency at which the pulses are received and th...”
21 / 2 ✓
1.00 “Disc according to claim 1” ≈ “DIGITAL CONTROL DEVICE The present invention relates to a digital control device...”
0.16 “the time-code signal is an absolute time-code signal that is...”
32 / 2 ✓
1.00 “Disc according to claim 1 or 2” ≈ “DIGITAL CONTROL DEVICE The present invention relates to a digital control device...”
0.38 “the time-code signal is modulated on a carrier frequency in...” ≈ “The speed is determined by the frequency at which the pulses are received and th...”
4 (indep.)2 / 4 ✓
0.38 “Apparatus for signal processing” ≈ “This is when a disc jockey stops the record from spinning whilst the platter con...”
0.47 “a digital audio source (1.10) and a record player (1.6) with...” ≈ “In all cases an electronic circuit (whether that be a stand alone unit, or part...”
0.30 “wherein during use the pick-up element (1.8) provides a time...”
0.29 “the pick-up element (1.8) feeds a digital filter (2.5, 2.6,...”
50 / 1
0.20 “it comprises a digital audio buffer being under control of t...”
60 / 1
0.31 “it comprises control logic (3.4) being fed by the time-code...”

Source: UK patent application 9804037.1 — Digital control device (filing receipt and specification, filed 25 Feb 1998).

How this is measured

The claims are compared as text only, without names or dates (added afterwards). Each claim is cut into its elements; elements are matched on their technical terms, with the field's synonyms meeting in one concept and rare terms counting for more than common ones. Every other pair of patents on the line is scored the same way, so a pair is judged against its class, not in isolation. An element said by earlier patents counts for little in the fingerprint; an element nobody said before counts in full. The method, the thresholds and every match are shown so that any of them can be challenged.