US7238874B2 and US7394731B2

How closely the two claim sets say the same things, and how unusual that is among the patents on the same line. Closeness of wording is a reason to look, not a finding: these documented facts raise questions; whether anyone had access, and whether the later work was independent, are separate questions shown with their own records.

Earlier

US7238874B2

Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus

N2IT Holding BV · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2007-07-03

Later

US7394731B2

Information playback apparatus

Pioneer Corp · priority 2001-05-21 · published 2008-07-01

US7394731B2's priority date is 15 months after US7238874B2's.

How close, against the line

0.09 overlap of their claims (0 to 1) — closer than 55.4% of the 65 other pairs of patents on this line (rank 30; the typical pair scores 0.08).

Each tick is another pair of patents on the line, scored the same way; the dashed line is the typical pair; the dot is this pair.

What was new in US7238874B2, and what US7394731B2 repeats

Of US7238874B2's elements, 5 were new at its date (not said by the 5 earlier patents of the line held); US7394731B2 repeats 0 of them.

US7238874B2's elementNew at its dateClosest in US7394731B2
A disc for use in an apparatus
already said before: “A rotatable disc”
0.63 0.07 — no counterpart
a record player with a turntable
already said before: “A digital processing device according to one of the claims 4-8, wherein said element is ma...”
0.65 0.11 — no counterpart
an arm with a pick-up element disposed thereon, a digital filter fed by said pick-up element 0.89 0.09 — no counterpart
comprising a circuit for detecting and following a carrier frequency and a demodulation circuit for demodulating a time-code signal that is modulated on the carrier frequency in the audible range between 20 and 20,000 Hz 0.81 0.08 — no counterpart
the disc comprising: a groove which can be followed by said pick-up element of said apparatus 0.79 0.05 — no counterpart
said groove comprises said time-code signal modulated on a carrier frequency in the audible range between 20 Hz and 20,000 Hz wherein said time-code signal is an absolute time-code signal that is comprised in the groove in a predetermined number of subsequently arranged discrete steps 0.87 0.03 — no counterpart
wherein the time-code signal is comprised in both left and right channel of the groove, having a mutual phase shift which provides directionality when said pickup element is lowered onto a rotating disc 0.92 0.08 — no counterpart
wherein said time code signal controls reproduction speed and direction by said digital audio source
already said before: “the speed and the direction of reproduction of said audio signal being manually controllab...”
0.60 0.24 — no counterpart
How this is measured

The claims are compared as text only, without names or dates (added afterwards). Each claim is cut into its elements; elements are matched on their technical terms, with the field's synonyms meeting in one concept and rare terms counting for more than common ones. Every other pair of patents on the line is scored the same way, so a pair is judged against its class, not in isolation. An element said by earlier patents counts for little in the fingerprint; an element nobody said before counts in full. The method, the thresholds and every match are shown so that any of them can be challenged.