Product1998-02prototype Carroll, Steven

Carroll DVS — timecode vinyl concept

Cite this on a line: [[product:78d47b61-a9dc-4587-80b7-03da1ee87c35]]

Work 4 of 21 dated on the dvs line, 3 years after the first documented work (WO1997001168A1).

Available1998-02 – end not known
from: the dated record of this product
Price at launch not known
Where made not known
Warranty not known
Units sold not known
Model number not known
Documents held11
Its life, in dated steps1
this product ended or discontinued candidate, not yet confirmed other work on the same line, by others
WhenWhat the record shows
1998-02Prototype (the dated record)

Other work on the same line in those years, by others:

Photographs1
People and companies1
Disputes and cases3
  • Third-party observations against N2IT application EP 01 908 437.5 (EPO) patent officeunknown
    European Patent Office (Examining Division; Board of Appeal) · EP 01 908 437.5 · 2003-12 · shown because it filed on its line

    Prior art from Chris Bauer's 1998 Middlesex MA thesis/prototype put to the EPO against N2IT's Final Scratch application; N2IT responded 9 Apr 2004; refusal and appeal followed.

    1. 2003-12-03 · filed: Observations by third party filed against EP 01 908 437.5 source
    2. 2004-01-01 · decision: Application refused (per outside summary; date of refusal not sourced)
    3. 2004-04-09 · motion: Applicant (N2IT) response to the third-party observations source
    4. 2005-12-23 · appeal: Board of Appeal: patent granted on appeal (per outside summary; the reference 'EPO Appeal … Dec. 23, 2005' is cited in US 8,680,385) source
    the record
  • n2it v Native Instruments lawsuitunknown
    US District Court (CACD), R. Gary Klausner; referred to Victor B. Kenton · 2:07-cv-03321 · 2007-05–2007-07 · shown because it filed on its line

    First court case brought by n2it, against Native Instruments, the Berlin company that wrote the software for Final Scratch and then launched Traktor. Per Carroll it ended the Final Scratch branch.

    the record
  • n2it v M-Audio / Avid patent suitunknown
    US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller · 2:08-cv-00619 · 2008-12–2009-11 · shown because it filed on its line

    n2it against M-Audio and its parent Avid Technology (NASDAQ-listed): per Carroll, a listed company against a tiny inventor. Avid had top-tier counsel, a firm that also acted in Apple v Samsung (firm not named yet). An insider was involved: a director who moved from Avid to Stanton (not named yet). A...

    1. 2009-09-04 · counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.) source
    2. 2009-11-01 · ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held) source
    3. undated · prior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.
    Documents on this case: 45 The M Audio Torq Connection Paul Whittington and The N2IT Patent Sh... lead, not evidence · 57 The N2IT v M Audio Litigation Audit Hallucination vs Docket Reality... · 55 The N2IT v M Audio Federal Litigation Dossier EDVa 08cv619 lead, not evidence
    the record

A case is shown as filed and decided, in its own words; it is not a finding of this index.

The documents10

9 more documents are held but not shown publicly (write-ups, typed copies and other kinds that can carry private details).

Add to this product

A fact, a date in its life, or a document. Every addition needs a source, and a fact needs the words it rests on, quoted. It shows at once, marked candidate, until someone confirms it. Two sources that disagree are both kept. Prices and units are kept as the source states them.

Sign in to add a fact or a document.