EP0973162A2 and DE10206644C1
How closely the two claim sets say the same things, and how unusual that is among the patents on the same line. Closeness of wording is a reason to look, not a finding: these documented facts raise questions; whether anyone had access, and whether the later work was independent, are separate questions shown with their own records.
EP0973162A2
System for reproducing information recorded on a disc
Pioneer Electronic Corp · priority 1998-07-09 · published 2000-01-19
DE10206644C1
Playback device for digitally-stored music information uses control device linked to disc player for controlling playback parameters
Native Instruments Software Synthesis GmbH · priority 2002-02-15 · published 2003-07-17
DE10206644C1's priority date is 43 months after EP0973162A2's.
0.06 overlap of their claims (0 to 1) — closer than 18.5% of the 65 other pairs of patents on this line (rank 54; the typical pair scores 0.08).
Each tick is another pair of patents on the line, scored the same way; the dashed line is the typical pair; the dot is this pair.
Of EP0973162A2's elements, 13 were new at its date (not said by the 2 earlier patents of the line held); DE10206644C1 repeats 0 of them.
| EP0973162A2's element | New at its date | Closest in DE10206644C1 |
|---|---|---|
| A system for reproducing music information recorded on a disc already said before: “said means reproducing a piece when said disc rotates” |
0.59 | 0.12 — no counterpart |
| a reproducing system for reproducing music recorded on a digital disc, having a spindle motor for rotating a turntable | 0.72 | 0.12 — no counterpart |
| a rotating dial to be rotated by a user | 0.81 | 0.10 — no counterpart |
| detecting means for detecting a rotating condition of the rotating dial | 0.82 | 0.03 — no counterpart |
| processing means responsive to a detected rotating condition for processing reproduced music | 0.74 | 0.10 — no counterpart |
| the processing means is provided for delaying the reproduced music information in accordance with the detected rotating condition. | 0.76 | 0.11 — no counterpart |
| the processing means is provided for changing the pitch of the reproduced music information in accordance with the detected rotating condition. | 0.80 | 0.11 — no counterpart |
| the processing means is provided for changing a frequency range of the reproduced music information in accordance with the detected rotating condition. | 0.81 | 0.10 — no counterpart |
| the processing means is provided for returning a processed music information to an initial condition when the rotating dial is stopped. | 0.90 | 0.09 — no counterpart |
| The system according to claim 1 wherein the rotating condition already said before: “A rotatable disc” |
0.64 | 0.03 — no counterpart |
| an amount of rotation and rotating direction | 0.72 | 0.03 — no counterpart |
| The system according to claim 2 wherein the delaying operation | 1.00 | 0.02 — no counterpart |
| the repeating of the increasing and reducing of the delay time | 1.00 | 0.16 — no counterpart |
| the pitch is changed by changing the rotating speed of the spindle motor. | 0.84 | 0.03 — no counterpart |
| the frequency range is changed by shifting a frequency range of a band pass filter. | 1.00 | 0.03 — no counterpart |
The claims are compared as text only, without names or dates (added afterwards). Each claim is cut into its elements; elements are matched on their technical terms, with the field's synonyms meeting in one concept and rare terms counting for more than common ones. Every other pair of patents on the line is scored the same way, so a pair is judged against its class, not in isolation. An element said by earlier patents counts for little in the fingerprint; an element nobody said before counts in full. The method, the thresholds and every match are shown so that any of them can be challenged.