InventionEP0973162A21998-07-09Pioneer Electronic Corp

Music disc player with a jog dial that changes playback

Cite this on a line: [[patent:EP0973162A2]]

Work 5 of 21 dated on the dvs line, 3 years after the first documented work (WO1997001168A1).

What happened to this patent

Expired at the end of its term; never challenged on the record expired at the end of its term

A grant is a presumption, not a proof: the status is read from the record below. Its weight as evidence of origin: 0.6 (survived a challenge 1.0 · never challenged 0.6 · let lapse 0.5 · contested 0.3 · abandoned under challenge 0).

WhenWhat the record showsWhere
1999-07-06Application filed by Pioneer Electronic CorpUS6576825B2
1999-07-06Assigned to PIONEER ELECTRONIC CORPORATIONownership
1999-07-08Application filed by Pioneer Electronic CorpEP0973162A2
2000-01-19Publication of EP0973162A2EP0973162A2
2000-05-17Publication of EP0973162A3EP0973162A2
2001-08-09Publication of US20010011497A1US6576825B2
2003-05-16Priority to US10/439,012US6576825B2
2003-06-10Application grantedUS6576825B2
2003-06-10Publication of US6576825B2US6576825B2
2009-09-16Application grantedEP0973162A2
2009-09-16Publication of EP0973162B1EP0973162A2
2014-12-09Assigned to PIONEER CORPORATIONownership
2015-03-30Assigned to PIONEER DJ CORPORATIONownership
2015-12-01Assigned to PDJ HOLDINGS CORPORATIONownership
2015-12-03Assigned to PIONEER DJ CORPORATIONownership
2019-07-06Anticipated expirationUS6576825B2
2019-07-08Anticipated expirationEP0973162A2
2020-06-05Assigned to ALPHATHETA CORPORATIONownership
undatedExpired - LifetimeUS6576825B2

Earlier work on the same line, before its priority (1998-07-09)

Dated work by other makers that came before the patent's priority date: prior art for a reader to weigh, whether or not the examiner saw it.

How it was examined

Earlier filings on this line that were not published by this patent's filing date, so could not have been cited: GB9804037.1application (1998-02-01), GB9804037D0 (1998-02-25).

The office's own examination record (search, objections, amendments, grant) is not held yet for this patent.

The filing itself

At the office: European Patent Register — its procedure, the examiner's communications and the documents of the file

At the office: Espacenet

Compare its claims

Claim by claim against another patent on the same line, with the pair placed among every pair on the line:

WO1997001168A1 1995 GB9804037D0 1998 EP0977171A1 1998 US7012184B2 2000 EP1312090B1 2000 US7238874B2 2000 US8680385B2 2000 US7394731B2 2001 DE10206644C1 2002 US7273980B2 2004

The problem

The text's only account of earlier art is that music is now generally recorded on discs such as CDs. It does not say what those players lacked. The text held gives no further detail on the problem.

The idea

A digital disc player has a rotating control that the user turns by hand. The player senses how the control is turned and changes the music it plays to match. This lets a listener shape the playback of a CD-style disc directly with the hand.

How it works

A motor spins the digital disc, and a reproducing section reads the music information recorded on it. The player also has a rotating device that the user can turn freely, and in the granted claim this device is a jog dial. A detection section watches the jog dial and measures its rotational state. That state includes how far the dial has been turned and which direction it was turned. A processing section takes the music information being reproduced and changes it according to the detected state. The text held does not say what the changes are, such as speed, direction or position. The abstract describes the same arrangement more generally. It speaks of a rotatable body, a detection section for its rotational state, and a processing section that handles the music according to that state.

The claims, in plain words

  1. An audio player for music on a digital disc has a motor that spins the disc, a user-turned rotating device, a detector for the device's rotational state (amount and direction), a reproducing section, and a processing section that changes the reproduced music according to that state. The rotating device is a jog dial.

How broad it is

The granted claim covers audio players for music recorded on a digital disc. These players have a disc-spinning motor and a user-turned jog dial whose amount and direction of rotation are detected and used to process the music. The earlier application claim was wider. It covered a system with a spindle motor and turntable and a rotating dial, with no mention of direction. The text held does not name other media, other kinds of control, or specific uses.

What survived examination

The granted claim is narrower and more specific than the application claim. It adds that the rotating device is a jog dial. It also adds that the detected rotational state includes both the amount of rotation and the rotating direction. It states the disc-spinning motor and a separate reproducing means directly, in place of the application's spindle motor, turntable and reproducing system.

A machine's plain-language description of the patent's own text (antigravity:claude-sonnet-5-5-medium, 2026-11-20), not a legal opinion on validity or infringement. Read from the claim and abstract held only.

Named on the patent11
People and companies1
Disputes and cases3
  • Third-party observations against N2IT application EP 01 908 437.5 (EPO) patent officeunknown
    European Patent Office (Examining Division; Board of Appeal) · EP 01 908 437.5 · 2003-12 · shown because it filed on its line

    Prior art from Chris Bauer's 1998 Middlesex MA thesis/prototype put to the EPO against N2IT's Final Scratch application; N2IT responded 9 Apr 2004; refusal and appeal followed.

    1. 2003-12-03 · filed: Observations by third party filed against EP 01 908 437.5 source
    2. 2004-01-01 · decision: Application refused (per outside summary; date of refusal not sourced)
    3. 2004-04-09 · motion: Applicant (N2IT) response to the third-party observations source
    4. 2005-12-23 · appeal: Board of Appeal: patent granted on appeal (per outside summary; the reference 'EPO Appeal … Dec. 23, 2005' is cited in US 8,680,385) source
    the record
  • n2it v Native Instruments lawsuitunknown
    US District Court (CACD), R. Gary Klausner; referred to Victor B. Kenton · 2:07-cv-03321 · 2007-05–2007-07 · shown because it filed on its line

    First court case brought by n2it, against Native Instruments, the Berlin company that wrote the software for Final Scratch and then launched Traktor. Per Carroll it ended the Final Scratch branch.

    the record
  • n2it v M-Audio / Avid patent suitunknown
    US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller · 2:08-cv-00619 · 2008-12–2009-11 · shown because it filed on its line

    n2it against M-Audio and its parent Avid Technology (NASDAQ-listed): per Carroll, a listed company against a tiny inventor. Avid had top-tier counsel, a firm that also acted in Apple v Samsung (firm not named yet). An insider was involved: a director who moved from Avid to Stanton (not named yet). A...

    1. 2009-09-04 · counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.) source
    2. 2009-11-01 · ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held) source
    3. undated · prior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.
    Documents on this case: 45 The M Audio Torq Connection Paul Whittington and The N2IT Patent Sh... lead, not evidence · 57 The N2IT v M Audio Litigation Audit Hallucination vs Docket Reality... · 55 The N2IT v M Audio Federal Litigation Dossier EDVa 08cv619 lead, not evidence
    the record

A case is shown as filed and decided, in its own words; it is not a finding of this index.

Documents in the family

  • EP0973162A2 · priority 1998-07-09 · published 2000-01-19 · granted 2009-09-16 · source Google Patents
  • US6576825B2 · priority 1998-07-09 · published 2003-06-10 · granted 2003-06-10 · source Google Patents

Cited by 74 later documents held.

Later documents that cite it (74)

  • US7058462B1 · 1999 · Sony Computer Entertainment Inc.
    Entertainment system, entertainment apparatus, recording medium, and program
  • US20140313871A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and Method for Controlling Audio Source
  • US20060130639A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • US7238874B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • US8198524B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Apparatus for controlling a digital source
  • NL1014526C2 · 2000 · N2It Dev B V I O
    Disc to be used in a signal processing device as well as such a device.
  • US8802954B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling audio source
  • US7012184B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • US9218844B2 · 2000 · Native Instruments Gmbh
    System and method for controlling audio source
  • US8502058B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling audio equipment
  • US8680385B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling a digital audio source
  • US20020181378A1 · 2000 · Mark-Jan Bastian
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • US8217252B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling play of digital audio equipment
  • US20100077909A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Method for signal processing and an apparatus therefore
  • US20090277323A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Apparatus for Controlling a Digital Audio Signal
  • US8097800B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Method for controlling a digital audio source
  • EP1152393B1 · 2000 · Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
    Audio reproduction apparatus having audio modulation function, method used by the apparatus and remixing appar...
  • KR100387238B1 · 2000 · 삼성전자주식회사
    Audio reproducing apparatus and method having function capable of modulating audio signal, remixing apparatus...
  • US20050275626A1 · 2000 · Color Kinetics Incorporated
    Entertainment lighting system
  • US7087830B2 · 2001 · Justin A. Kent
    System for converting turntable motion to MIDI data
  • US20030029305A1 · 2001 · Kent Justin A.
    System for converting turntable motion to MIDI data
  • AU2002326553B2 · 2001 · Justin A Kent
    System for converting turntable motion to midi data
  • DE10206644C1 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Playback device for digitally-stored music information uses control device linked to disc player for controlli...
  • WO2003069599A3 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • GB2388243B · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • US7010371B2 · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • GB2388243A · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • US6818815B2 · 2002 · Stanton Magnetics Inc.
    Phonograph turntable with MIDI output
  • US20030206506A1 · 2002 · Laurent Cohen
    Phonograph turntable with MIDI output
  • US6745091B2 · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • US6961289B2 · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • GB2388462A · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having a stimulated analogue record
  • GB2388461A · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having simulated analogue record
  • GB2388461B · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • GB2388462B · 2002 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • EP1391889A3 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Switch device, data-processing apparatus and playback apparatus
  • EP1391887A3 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Switch device, data-processing apparatus and playback apparatus
  • JP4084617B2 · 2002 · パイオニア株式会社
    Switch device, information processing device, and playback device
  • JP4136539B2 · 2002 · パイオニア株式会社
    Information processing apparatus, method, program, recording medium for recording program, and playback appara...
  • JP4189182B2 · 2002 · パイオニア株式会社
    Switch device, information processing device, and playback device
  • EP1391888A3 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Information processing unit, information processing method, program for the same, recording medium for recordi...
  • US7787342B2 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Information processing unit, information processing method, program for the same, recording medium for recordi...
  • US7294796B2 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Switch device, data-processing apparatus and playback apparatus
  • US7269103B2 · 2002 · Pioneer Corporation
    Switch device, data-processing apparatus and playback apparatus
  • JP4075654B2 · 2003 · ティアック株式会社
    Audio signal playback device
  • US7742686B2 · 2003 · Pioneer Corporation
    Signal processor
  • EP1519386A3 · 2003 · Pioneer Corporation
    Signal processor
  • EP1519384A3 · 2003 · Pioneer Corporation
    Signal processor
  • JP2005109657A · 2003 · Pioneer Electronic Corp
    Signal processing device
  • US7751684B2 · 2003 · Pioneer Corporation
    Signal processor
  • JP4313639B2 · 2003 · パイオニア株式会社
    Signal processing device
  • US7763843B2 · 2004 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.
    Optical navigation system for rotary control based non-contact controller
  • WO2005084339A2 · 2004 · Color Kinetics Incorporated
    Entertainment lighting system
  • KR101403806B1 · 2005 · 오디오브락스 인더스트리아 에 코메르씨오 데 프로두토스 엘레트로니코스 에스.에이.
    Mobile communication device with music instrumental functions
  • WO2006104108A1 · 2005 · Pioneer Corporation
    Information reproducing device and method, and computer program
  • JPWO2006104109A1 · 2005 · パイオニア株式会社
    Information reproducing apparatus and method, DJ equipment, and computer program
  • KR20070010589A · 2005 · 엘지전자 주식회사
    Mobile communication terminal provided with a turntable and its operation method
  • US20080013756A1 · 2006 · Numark Industries, Llc
    Media storage manager and player
  • US20080121092A1 · 2006 · Gci Technologies Corp.
    Digital media DJ mixer
  • US20100080109A1 · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.
    Variable Slippage Control For A Disc Jockey Control Surface

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

Earlier documents it cites (16)

  • US2471534A · 1943 · Muth William
    Musical instrument
  • US2839960A · 1949 · Baldwin Piano Co
    Electronic synchronizing system for producing pitch discs and the like
  • US3197543A · 1958 · Dimension Inc
    Photoelectric organ
  • US4768413A · 1986 · Nippon Gakki Seizo Kabushiki Kaisha
    Automatic performance apparatus for facilitating editing of prerecorded data
  • JPS62175796A · 1986 · ヤマハ株式会社
    Automatic performer
  • JPH02203485A · 1989 · Pioneer Electron Corp
    Playing device for information recording medium
  • US5038660A · 1989 · Pioneer Electronic Corporation
    Recording medium playing apparatus with program discontinuity response
  • US5350882A · 1991 · Casio Computer Co., Ltd.
    Automatic performance apparatus with operated rotation means for tempo control
  • JP2734909B2 · 1992 · ヤマハ株式会社
    Waveform data reading device
  • US5670729A · 1993 · Virtual Music Entertainment, Inc.
    Virtual music instrument with a novel input device
  • US5734731A · 1994 · Marx; Elliot S.
    Real time audio mixer
  • EP0880779A1 · 1995 · André Rickli
    Digital processing device for audio signal
  • CN1096070C · 1995 · 索尼公司
    Optical disk reproduction appts. and optical disk reproduction method
  • US5925843A · 1997 · Virtual Music Entertainment, Inc.
    Song identification and synchronization
  • JPH1186446A · 1997 · Sony Corp
    Data reproducing apparatus and data reproducing method
  • US5969283A · 1998 · Looney Productions, Llc
    Music organizer and entertainment center

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

The documents0

No documents linked yet. Anyone holding one can bring it from the line's "Edit this line".