InventionEP1312090B12000-02-29N2IT Holding BV

Vinyl disc with a time-code groove to control digital audio playback

Cite this on a line: [[patent:EP1312090B1]]

Work 8 of 21 dated on the dvs line, 5 years after the first documented work (WO1997001168A1).

What happened to this patent

Enforcement abandoned by the owner under challenge challenged in n2it v M-Audio / Avid (counterclaim or prior art), then withdrawn or dismissed before any ruling

A grant is a presumption, not a proof: the status is read from the record below. Its weight as evidence of origin: 0.0 (survived a challenge 1.0 · never challenged 0.6 · let lapse 0.5 · contested 0.3 · abandoned under challenge 0).

WhenWhat the record showsWhere
2001-01-26Application filed by N2IT Holding BVEP1312090B1
2002-04-26Application filed by N2IT Holding BVUS7012184B2
2002-08-05Assigned to N2IT HOLDING B.V.ownership
2002-08-05Assigned to N2IT DEVELOPMENT B.V.ownership
2002-12-05Publication of US20020181378A1US7012184B2
2003-05-21Publication of EP1312090A1EP1312090B1
2006-02-15Priority to US11/355,851US7238874B2
2006-02-15Application filed by N2IT Holding BVUS7238874B2
2006-03-14Application grantedUS7012184B2
2006-03-14Publication of US7012184B2US7012184B2
2006-05-12Assigned to N2IT HOLDING B.V.ownership
2006-06-22Publication of US20060130639A1US7238874B2
2007-07-03Application grantedUS7238874B2
2007-07-03Priority to US11/773,195US7238874B2
2007-07-03Publication of US7238874B2US7238874B2
2008-02-13Application grantedEP1312090B1
2008-02-13Publication of EP1312090B1EP1312090B1
2008-12-23Asserted in court: n2it v M-Audio / Avid (US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller)court
2009-07-22Priority to US12/507,242US7238874B2
2009-09-04counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.)court
2009-11-01ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held)court
2009-11-17Case closed: n2it v M-Audio / Avidcourt
2009-12-03Priority to US12/630,323US7238874B2
2012-01-16Priority to US13/351,112US7238874B2
2012-06-11Priority to US13/493,787US7238874B2
2012-06-11Application filed by N2IT Holding BVUS8680385B2
2012-07-09Priority to US13/544,194US7238874B2
2012-10-04Publication of US20120253494A1US8680385B2
2013-08-05Priority to US13/959,444US7238874B2
2014-03-25Priority to US14/225,122US7238874B2
2014-03-25Application grantedUS8680385B2
2014-03-25Publication of US8680385B2US8680385B2
2014-05-14Assigned to N2IT HOLDING B.V.ownership
2014-06-04Assigned to N2IT HOLDING B.V.ownership
2014-07-01Priority to US14/320,895US7238874B2
2014-10-07Assigned to NATIVE INSTRUMENTS GMBHownership
2021-01-26Anticipated expirationUS8680385B2
2022-01-07Adjusted expirationUS7012184B2
2022-04-26Anticipated expirationUS7238874B2
undatedFirst worldwide family litigation filedcourt
undatedExpired - LifetimeUS7238874B2
undatedExpired - Fee RelatedUS8680385B2
undatedUS case filed in Virginia Eastern District Courtcourt
undatedprior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.court

Earlier work on the same line, before its priority (2000-02-29)

Dated work by other makers that came before the patent's priority date: prior art for a reader to weigh, whether or not the examiner saw it.

How it was examined

Earlier patents on this line that were not cited

  • EP0977171A1 1998-07-31 · Audio signal processing apparatus · Pioneer Electronic Corp

Published patents on the same line, earlier than this one's filing, that neither the examiner nor the applicant cited (family members of a citation count as cited). The examiner may have had reasons; the earlier art is on the record for a reader to weigh.

Earlier filings on this line that were not published by this patent's filing date, so could not have been cited: GB9804037.1application (1998-02-01), GB9804037D0 (1998-02-25).

The office's own examination record (search, objections, amendments, grant) is not held yet for this patent.

The filing itself

At the office: European Patent Register — its procedure, the examiner's communications and the documents of the file

At the office: Espacenet

Compare its claims

Claim by claim against another patent on the same line, with the pair placed among every pair on the line:

WO1997001168A1 1995 GB9804037D0 1998 EP0973162A2 1998 US6576825B2 1998 EP0977171A1 1998 US7394731B2 2001 DE10206644C1 2002 US7273980B2 2004

The problem

Earlier equipment let a CD player follow a rotating element on a turntable. It allowed only continuously developing movements and could not give the authentic scratch sound of a conventional record. That made it hardly usable by disc jockeys. The text wants a digital sound source that behaves like a conventional record and lets recorded fragments be located quickly.

The idea

A record-style disc carries a time-code signal in its groove. A normal turntable and needle read the signal, and it controls a digital audio source. A DJ can then scratch and cue digital music the way they would with a conventional record.

How it works

The disc is made with the same methods used for conventional records: recording, making a master disc, and pressing vinyl. Its groove holds a time-code signal modulated on a carrier frequency in the audible range, 20 to 20,000 Hz. The disc sits on the turntable of a record player. The pick-up element on the arm follows the groove. A digital filter fed by the pick-up detects and follows the carrier frequency, and a demodulation circuit recovers the time-code signal. The signal is an absolute time-code, written in a set number of discrete steps one after another. It is in both the left and right channels, with a phase shift between them. That shift gives direction, so the direction of play is known as soon as the needle is lowered onto the rotating disc, with no noticeable delay. The time-code then controls the reproduction speed and direction of the digital audio source.

The claims, in plain words

  1. A disc for use with a record player (turntable, arm and pick-up element) and a digital filter fed by the pick-up. The filter has a circuit that detects and follows a carrier frequency and a circuit that demodulates the time-code.
  2. The disc has a groove that the pick-up element can follow.
  3. The groove holds a time-code signal modulated on a carrier frequency between 20 Hz and 20,000 Hz.
  4. The time-code is an absolute time-code, held in the groove in a set number of discrete steps arranged one after another.
  5. The time-code is in both the left and right channels of the groove, with a mutual phase shift that gives directionality when the pick-up is lowered onto a rotating disc.
  6. The time-code controls the reproduction speed and direction of the digital audio source.

How broad it is

The text covers a disc placed on a turntable with a groove the pick-up element can follow. The groove carries a time-code that controls a digital audio source. It describes use by disc jockeys and in scratch applications, and it says the disc is made with conventional record manufacturing. The granted claim is narrower. It requires an audible-range carrier of 20 to 20,000 Hz, an absolute time-code in discrete steps, and a phase-shifted time-code in both channels. Other media and uses are not stated in the text held.

A machine's plain-language description of the patent's own text (antigravity:claude-sonnet-5-5-medium, 2026-11-20), not a legal opinion on validity or infringement. Read from: EP1312090-epo-doclist.txt (capture, readability 0.846).

Named on the patent3
People and companies2
Related products, patents and papers1
Disputes and cases3
  • Third-party observations against N2IT application EP 01 908 437.5 (EPO) patent officeunknown
    European Patent Office (Examining Division; Board of Appeal) · EP 01 908 437.5 · 2003-12 · shown because it filed on its line

    Prior art from Chris Bauer's 1998 Middlesex MA thesis/prototype put to the EPO against N2IT's Final Scratch application; N2IT responded 9 Apr 2004; refusal and appeal followed.

    1. 2003-12-03 · filed: Observations by third party filed against EP 01 908 437.5 source
    2. 2004-01-01 · decision: Application refused (per outside summary; date of refusal not sourced)
    3. 2004-04-09 · motion: Applicant (N2IT) response to the third-party observations source
    4. 2005-12-23 · appeal: Board of Appeal: patent granted on appeal (per outside summary; the reference 'EPO Appeal … Dec. 23, 2005' is cited in US 8,680,385) source
    the record
  • n2it v Native Instruments lawsuitunknown
    US District Court (CACD), R. Gary Klausner; referred to Victor B. Kenton · 2:07-cv-03321 · 2007-05–2007-07 · shown because it a party is named on it: N2IT Holding BV

    First court case brought by n2it, against Native Instruments, the Berlin company that wrote the software for Final Scratch and then launched Traktor. Per Carroll it ended the Final Scratch branch.

    the record
  • n2it v M-Audio / Avid patent suitunknown
    US District Court (VAED), Henry C. Morgan, Jr; referred to Tommy E. Miller · 2:08-cv-00619 · 2008-12–2009-11 · shown because it a party is named on it: N2IT Holding B.V.

    n2it against M-Audio and its parent Avid Technology (NASDAQ-listed): per Carroll, a listed company against a tiny inventor. Avid had top-tier counsel, a firm that also acted in Apple v Samsung (firm not named yet). An insider was involved: a director who moved from Avid to Stanton (not named yet). A...

    1. 2009-09-04 · counterclaim: M-Audio, in US district court in Virginia, claims N2IT's patent unenforceable for inequitable conduct: withholding from the USPTO that the concept was public before filing, in Bauer's 1998 Middlesex thesis and a public demonstration. (Year inferred from article dated 29 Nov 2009.) source
    2. 2009-11-01 · ruling: Lawsuit reported dismissed (terms not given in the passage held) source
    3. undated · prior art: Avid's lawyers produce a prior-art counterclaim based on work by Chris Bauer at Middlesex University, said to date from March 1998. Date filed not yet given.
    Documents on this case: 45 The M Audio Torq Connection Paul Whittington and The N2IT Patent Sh... lead, not evidence · 57 The N2IT v M Audio Litigation Audit Hallucination vs Docket Reality... · 55 The N2IT v M Audio Federal Litigation Dossier EDVa 08cv619 lead, not evidence
    the record

A case is shown as filed and decided, in its own words; it is not a finding of this index.

Documents in the family

  • EP1312090B1 · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2008-02-13 · granted 2008-02-13 · source Google Patents
  • US7012184B2 · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2006-03-14 · granted 2006-03-14 · source Google Patents
  • US7238874B2 · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2007-07-03 · granted 2007-07-03 · source Google Patents
  • US8680385B2 · priority 2000-02-29 · published 2014-03-25 · granted 2014-03-25 · source Google Patents

Cited by 51 later documents held.

Later documents that cite it (51)

  • US20100077909A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Method for signal processing and an apparatus therefore
  • US9218844B2 · 2000 · Native Instruments Gmbh
    System and method for controlling audio source
  • US20140204722A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling a digital audio source
  • US20090277323A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Apparatus for Controlling a Digital Audio Signal
  • US8097800B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Method for controlling a digital audio source
  • US8198524B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Apparatus for controlling a digital source
  • US20070283798A1 · 2000 · N2It Holding B. V.
    Method for signal processing and an apparatus therefore
  • US8217252B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling play of digital audio equipment
  • US8680385B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling a digital audio source
  • US8802954B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling audio source
  • US8502058B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    System and method for controlling audio equipment
  • NL1014526C2 · 2000 · N2It Dev B V I O
    Disc to be used in a signal processing device as well as such a device.
  • GB2378805A · 2001 · Hanpin Electron Co Ltd
    Digital and analog audio signal apparatus
  • US8108524B2 · 2001 · Perftech, Inc.
    Internet connection user communications system
  • US7328266B2 · 2001 · Perftech, Inc.
    Internet provider subscriber communications system
  • DE10206644C1 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Playback device for digitally-stored music information uses control device linked to disc player for controlli...
  • US20080223197A1 · 2002 · Friedemann Becker
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • US7683249B2 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • GB0217856D0 · 2002 · Bahons Nik B
    Digital turntable
  • JP3830873B2 · 2002 · 株式会社ディーアンドエムホールディングス
    Optical disk playback device
  • US8077568B2 · 2002 · Spencer Charles A
    Method and system for synchronizing information specific to a location on a surface with an external source
  • US6881949B2 · 2002 · Charles A. Spencer
    Method and system for synchronizing information specific to a location on a surface with an external source
  • US20050127309A1 · 2002 · Spencer Charles A.
    Method and system for synchronizing information specific to a location on a surface with an external source
  • US6890876B2 · 2002 · Univation Technologies, Llc
    Processes for producing fluorided catalysts from nitrogenous metallocenes
  • US20050052981A1 · 2003 · Brian Shim
    Record controlled sound playback device
  • US7273980B2 · 2004 · Wardle Scott A
    Position and velocity transducer using a phonograph disc and turntable
  • US20050152236A1 · 2004 · Wardle Scott A.
    Position and velocity transducer using a phonograph disc and turntable
  • WO2005070188A3 · 2004 · Scott A Wardle
    A position and velocity transducer using a phonograph disc and turntable
  • USD518814S1 · 2004 · Numark Industries, Llc
    Record controlled sound playback device
  • US20070079315A1 · 2005 · Gregor Mittersinker
    Hybrid turntable
  • US8311656B2 · 2006 · Inmusic Brands, Inc.
    Music and audio playback system
  • US20080013757A1 · 2006 · Carrier Chad M
    Music and audio playback system
  • US9619431B2 · 2006 · Inmusic Brands, Inc.
    Music and audio playback system
  • US8053660B2 · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.
    Variable slippage control for a disc jockey control surface
  • US7928313B2 · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.
    Variable slippage control for a disc jockey control surface
  • US20100080109A1 · 2006 · Stanton Magnetics, Inc.
    Variable Slippage Control For A Disc Jockey Control Surface
  • JP2008262021A · 2007 · Hiromi Murakami
    Phase switching device in electric musical instrument
  • US8110734B2 · 2008 · Gibson Guitar Corp.
    Position sensitive rotatable DJ control device
  • US20100014390A1 · 2008 · Stanton Magnetics Inc.
    Position sensitive rotatable DJ control device
  • US8362349B2 · 2009 · Gibson Guitar Corp.
    Touch pad disc jockey controller
  • US20110063230A1 · 2009 · James Mazur
    Touch Pad Disc Jockey Controller
  • US8675454B2 · 2010 · Native Instruments Gmbh
    Apparatus and method for signal processing
  • JP5561497B2 · 2012 · ヤマハ株式会社
    Waveform data generation apparatus and waveform data generation program
  • JP6145320B2 · 2013 · Pioneer DJ株式会社
    Audio playback device, audio playback system, audio playback device control method, and program
  • US8729375B1 · 2013 · Synth Table Partners
    Platter based electronic musical instrument
  • US9153219B1 · 2013 · Synth Table Partners
    Platter based electronic musical instrument
  • JP6412660B2 · 2015 · Pioneer DJ株式会社
    Record board, digital content playback system, digital content playback control system, digital content playba...
  • WO2017059301A1 · 2015 · Wilson Sidney G Jr
    A dj apparatus including an integrated removable fader component
  • US10593313B1 · 2019 · Peter Bacigalupo
    Platter based electronic musical instrument
  • US11611655B2 · 2021 · Comcast Cable Communications, Llc
    Systems and methods for processing calls
  • US12236926B2 · 2022 · Algoriddim Gmbh
    System for selection and playback of song versions from vinyl type control interfaces

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

Earlier documents it cites (95)

  • US3755792A · 1971 · N Harvey
    Digital data storage system
  • US4173164A · 1977 · Nippon Gakki Seizo Kabushiki Kaisha
    Electronic musical instrument with frequency modulation of a tone signal with an audible frequency signal
  • US4176328A · 1978 · Motorola, Inc.
    DC coupled bi-phase modulator
  • US4300225A · 1979 · Lambl George R
    Disco beat meter
  • JPS5677960A · 1979 · Sony Corp
    Generating circuit of counter clock signal for tape counter
  • US4363048A · 1979 · Sony Corporation
    Time counting clock generator
  • US5339301A · 1986 · U.S. Philips Corporation
    Optically readable record carrier for recording information, method and apparatus for manufacturing such, appa...
  • NL8700655A · 1986 · Philips Nv
    OPTICALLY READABLE RECORD CARRIER FOR RECORDING INFORMATION, A METHOD AND AN APPARATUS FOR MANUFACTURING SUCH...
  • NL8800151A · 1988 · Philips Nv
    METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR RECORDING AN INFORMATION SIGNAL
  • US4901300A · 1988 · U.S. Philips Corporation
    Method of and apparatus for recording an information signal
  • US5091899A · 1988 · Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd.
    Time code recording or reproducing apparatus and time code converter
  • EP0352338B1 · 1988 · Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd.
    Apparatus for recording or reproducing time code and time code convertor
  • US5185805A · 1990 · David Chiang
    Tuned deconvolution digital filter for elimination of loudspeaker output blurring
  • US5140614A · 1990 · Industrial Technology, Inc.
    Method and apparatus for detecting digital carrier signals on telephone cables
  • US5297167A · 1990 · Industrial Technology, Inc.
    Method and apparatus for detecting digital carrier signals on telephone cables
  • US5350882A · 1991 · Casio Computer Co., Ltd.
    Automatic performance apparatus with operated rotation means for tempo control
  • US5353275A · 1992 · Ct Sound 92
    Beat finder
  • JP2734909B2 · 1992 · ヤマハ株式会社
    Waveform data reading device
  • US5512704A · 1992 · Yamaha Corporation
    Electronic sound signal generator achieving scratch sound effect using scratch readout from waveform memory
  • US5345244A · 1993 · Trimble Navigation Limited
    Cordless SPS smart antenna device
  • JP2508972B2 · 1993 · カシオ計算機株式会社
    Sound signal processing device
  • US5572201A · 1994 · Federal Signal Corporation
    Alerting device and system for abnormal situations
  • WO1997001168A1 · 1995 · Rickli Andre
    Digital processing device for audio signal
  • EP0880779A1 · 1995 · André Rickli
    Digital processing device for audio signal
  • US5862106A · 1995 · Sony Corporation
    Optical disc reproducing apparatus and optical disc reproducing method
  • CN1096070C · 1995 · 索尼公司
    Optical disk reproduction appts. and optical disk reproduction method
  • JP3364824B2 · 1996 · ベスタクス株式会社
    Record player
  • EP0871173A2 · 1997 · Ricoh Company, Ltd.
    Recording timing control circuit for optical disk driving device
  • JP3708668B2 · 1997 · 株式会社リコー
    EFM output timing control circuit and recording timing control circuit
  • US6576825B2 · 1998 · Pioneer Electronic Corporation
    Audio reproduction apparatus for reproducing music information recorded on a digital disk
  • JP2000030372A · 1998 · Pioneer Electron Corp
    Audio player
  • US6584205B1 · 1999 · American Technology Corporation
    Modulator processing for a parametric speaker system
  • US20030185405A1 · 1999 · Spencer Michael E.
    Modulator processing for a parametric speaker system
  • US20080063214A1 · 1999 · American Technology Corporation
    Modulator processing for a parametric speaker system
  • WO2001065559A1 · 2000 · N2It Development B.V. I.O.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing, and such an apparatus
  • US7238874B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • US7012184B2 · 2000 · N2It Holding B.V.
    Disc for use in an apparatus for signal processing and such an apparatus
  • NL1014526C2 · 2000 · N2It Dev B V I O
    Disc to be used in a signal processing device as well as such a device.
  • DE10164686B4 · 2001 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Automatic detection and adjustment of tempo and phase of pieces of music and interactive music players based o...
  • US7615702B2 · 2001 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Automatic recognition and matching of tempo and phase of pieces of music, and an interactive music player base...
  • WO2002103671A2 · 2001 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Automatic generation of musical scratching effects
  • US7041892B2 · 2001 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Automatic generation of musical scratching effects
  • US20030029305A1 · 2001 · Kent Justin A.
    System for converting turntable motion to MIDI data
  • AU2002326553B2 · 2001 · Justin A Kent
    System for converting turntable motion to midi data
  • US7087830B2 · 2001 · Justin A. Kent
    System for converting turntable motion to MIDI data
  • US6618329B2 · 2001 · Hanpin Electron Co., Ltd.
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • US20030043701A1 · 2001 · Han-Chih Liu
    Digital audio signal player having a simulated analogue record
  • US7146011B2 · 2001 · Nanyang Technological University
    Steering of directional sound beams
  • WO2003019125A1 · 2001 · Nanyang Techonological University
    Steering of directional sound beams
  • US6541690B1 · 2001 · Jerry W. Segers, Jr.
    Scratch effect controller
  • US20080223197A1 · 2002 · Friedemann Becker
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • DE10206644C1 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Playback device for digitally-stored music information uses control device linked to disc player for controlli...
  • US7683249B2 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthesis Gmbh
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • US20050081699A1 · 2002 · Friedemann Becker
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • US7235732B2 · 2002 · Native Instruments Software Synthensis Gmbh
    Device and method for controlling playback devices for digital information, especially music information
  • US6818815B2 · 2002 · Stanton Magnetics Inc.
    Phonograph turntable with MIDI output
  • JP2003346469A · 2002 · Denon Ltd
    Optical disc playback device
  • US6985418B2 · 2002 · Denon, Ltd.
    Optical disk reproducing apparatus
  • US7257072B2 · 2002 · Teac Corporation
    Digital audio data reproducing system
  • US20040004925A1 · 2002 · Tomohiko Kikuchi
    Digital audio data reproducing system

A number linked here opens its own page in this index where it is held, or the patent office's page where it is not yet read.

What we are still finding out3
  • Which products use the invention in EP1312090B1, and on what evidence (patent marking, manuals, court records)? open
  • Was EP1312090B1 litigated, opposed or licensed? Name the cases, forums and outcomes, with sources. open
  • Why did EP1312090B1 take 4 years to grant: what objections did the examiner raise and how were they answered? waiting for a source

The index asks these itself, every night, for each relationship a page like this should have; research questions run when someone asks. Each answer says what kind of witness gave it. Answers are leads until a person confirms them, and marking them useful or wrong teaches the index which provider to ask next time.

The documents0

No documents linked yet. Anyone holding one can bring it from the line's "Edit this line".